Archive for the ‘Real Estate’ Category
Reverse Mortgages
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Real Estate, Retirement on September 3rd, 2009

Quick - Name who's on the $50 bill!
What are reverse mortgages? In what situation would I need one or use one? How do they differ from a home equity loan?
I got the question above via email from a reader. I know the basics of what a reverse mortgage is, but, being a man who owns a bunch of old law textbooks that have very little value to me now that I’m out of law school (other than looking cool on my shelf), I turned first to my Nelson/Whitman text, Real Estate Finance, Transfer and Development.
It’s an excellent book, and has a wealth of legal knowledge. In fact, when I was in school I would have told you with a straight face that it would tell you everything you needed to know to be a practicing attorney in the area of real estate law. That’s a very naive thing to think, but it is a very good text if you’re in the market (and why would you be). The book doesn’t have much to say abut reverse mortgages, just a couple pages (out of over 1200).
According to the book, a reverse mortgage, or a reverse annuity mortgage (RAM), (also known as a home equity conversion mortgage) allows retired people with lots of equity in their homes to borrow from that equity on a regular basis to pay living expenses. The lender basically makes monthly disbursements to the homeowner, which essentially bleeds the equity they’ve built. The lender predetermines the maximum amount they are willing to lend out of the house, preserving enough equity to ensure that eventually they can sell the house and get their money back.
The book says this as well, “The balance will ultimately reach the maximum level acceptable to the lender, at which time the loan will have to be repaid, presumably requiring the sale of the property.”
These guys know more about this stuff than I do, but I think that’s misleading. That seems to suggest that as soon as you reach that maximum level, the loan has to be repaid – and that the house will be sold. This would be based on the specific terms of the agreement that you enter into, but I think most reverse mortgages are predicated on the fact that you can take the money until you reach the limit (they’re not going to give you an endless supply of money), and then you can stay in your house until you die or vacate it. I doubt this is an error on the part of Professor Whitman (who taught my Property law bar class a little over a year ago and a leader in this field) or his coauthor. I think this is probably just worded in a way that’s a little bit ambiguous;)
There are multiple ways these sorts of agreements work. Sometimes an annuity is purchased from a lump sum disbursement. Sometimes they just make monthly payments. In either case, you’re borrowing money, and the money you’ve borrowed is accruing interest. That’s one way the people making these loans. The other way is through closing the loans (here’s a guide to some of the different types of payment options). When one of these loans is made, there are closing costs just like with any other loan. Before you consider taking one of these, ask for a term sheet with all of the estimated closing costs. Keep this in mind when you’re shopping for a reverse mortgages – it’s not just the interest rate that matters, it’s the total amount of money involved.
If this sounds a lot like a home equity loan – it is, but with one fundamental difference…you don’t have to start making payments immediately after getting the loan. This works more like a balloon loan. All of the money will be due at some point in the future, usually from the sale of the home.
Finally, these loans are only for retirees (you have to be at least 62 to take one). Ideally, you’ll be in a position during retirement where you don’t need to take one of these (if you wanted to know more, here’s a comprehensive guide to reverse mortgages). If you haven’t started saving for retirement, start now! Even if you can only afford to invest a small amount of money each month, get in the game if you can. If you end up having to rely on a reverse mortgage, the option is there, but it’s a worst case scenario. Thanks for reading.
Only a Business Owner Can Sell Like a Business Owner
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Entrepreneurship, Interviews, Real Estate on August 19th, 2009

This is my second attempt at interviewing someone on the blog. Like the previous interview, we did it all by email. If anything got lost in translation, let me know, and I’ll try to sort it out! The end product made sense to me, so hopefully it will make sense to you as well. My goal going forward is to include two interviews on the blog per month. I’m going to try to focus on entrepreneurs, but I’ll also probably interview a variety of people who know how to do something specific that I’ve never done before.
The interviewee today is Chris Majerle. Chris was kind enough to answer some questions about his property management company, MMI. MMI (Majerle Management, Inc.) has been in business since 1987, and Chris has managed to grow his business to include more than 1100 units. If you’re in the market for someone to manage your rentals in the D.C. area, check them out. But enough from me, I’ll let him tell you in his own words.
What is your educational background?
Two years of college with an emphasis on biology and health sciences. Originally, I was interested in Pharmacy or Anesthesia. That wasn’t for me! I saw an ad for a real estate agent, took the 45 hour course and got my license. Once into the field, I continued my training by securing my Graduate Realtor’s Institute (GRI) designation, my broker’s license and later took a series of classes and exams, culminating in a case study, to earn the Professional Community Association Manager (PCAM) designation.
What (if anything) did you do career wise before you got into real estate?
This was my first real career—I started in real estate sales and migrated toward the property management specialty.
How did you transition from real estate sales into property management?
When I was a kid, I worked on our house with my dad. He painted, finished basements and did all the maintenance and yard work. Sometimes, for a few extra dollars, he did some of this for others. I tagged along. I’m talking about doing this work at 8 or 10 years old. And I never stopped. I painted houses while in college. I never bought a nice house for myself-only fixer-uppers. And I got my home improvement license so I could do it for others. As you can imagine, knowing how to fix just about anything is a definite plus for a property manager. Now, 33 years later, I still do all of it. Today, we have the home improvement business to help support the property management business.
Customer service is more than answering the phone nicely; it’s being able to get to the root of the problem and suggest a solution. With the maintenance skills in my pocket, I answer a call expecting that the caller really doesn’t understand the real problem. If the refrigerator is stopped, I want to know whether the bulb comes on with the door open. If not (assuming it did yesterday), there’s a pretty good chance we don’t need an appliance service call. We may need a breaker reset or an electrician. All we need to do is run an extension cord from another outlet. Similar efforts can aid in diagnosing the real source of a water leak, an air conditioning or heating problem or a water problem.
For me, the transition was crying out, I belonged on the rental management side.
What does property management entail?
Everyone thinks we collect rent, take our fee and send the rest to the owner. But there can be a bit more. Certainly, balancing the desires of the tenant, the orders from the local inspectors (or the knowledge of the housing code) and the financial wishes of the owner can present challenges. We are big believers in fixing things before they deteriorate to the point where replacement is the only option. Real estate is a long-term investment and we should look at the big picture from the maintenance perspective.
Today, property management is an information business. Our services, including receipt of payments, rental applications and processing, maintenance service requests, owner payment disbursements and more are online. Often, we juggle two or three software packages, all online (ASP), to fulfill everyone’s desire. All these packages must talk to each other seamlessly.
But what is information without the knowledge to back it up? In our jurisdiction, virtually every rental unit must be licensed by the county or the city. Many are eligible to or mandated to participate in a state-run lead poisoning prevention program. Owners need counsel on property insurance, taxes, mortgage planning, home remodeling and more. We are expected to provide enough information to give owners the intelligent questions they need to take to their insurance or mortgage brokers, attorneys and accountants. We don’t give advice; that would be illegal. Alternatively, if we don’t, we would be negligent. We walk a tightrope!
Other services include property inspection; not the type you would pay $400 to a property inspector to obtain, but a periodic visit to the property to examine the overall property maintenance condition and the tenancy performance. These visits, every six months at our firm, are followed by a written report to the owner, often with photos. We prepare vacancies for market, we advertise for tenants, we screen applicants for credit, income and rental history, we prepare leases, we collect rents, pay bills, disburse owner funds and report all of this on an income statement each month. When tenants vacate, we inspect for damage, assess the costs, account or the security deposit, make the disbursements and start the vacancy marketing process all over again.
Again, it’s a long term investment. Owners need information and help maximizing the long-term profit, much of which comes from the eventual sale. That information comes from our real estate experience and our REALTOR membership. We have access to MLS data and know how to sell. Thus, we are in a position to keep owners apprised of the value and marketability of their properties – not all rental managers are licensed as it is not required, even here in Maryland.
When did you go into business for yourself? What prompted the decision? What was initially necessary? Did you form a business entity (what type – LLC, Corp., etc.)? What services did you outsource initially? Legal services? Accounting? Did you talk to a CPA?
I made the jump to property management in 1982, at a time when many real estate companies were failing. The firm I was with had 27 offices and closed. I jumped to a small, franchised real estate company hoping to retain a portion of my management portfolio, and I did. After 4 years, I found that my department remained a stepchild. I had absolutely no support, even though I was generating more income than any other agent in the firm. I left and struck out on my own. I did it with a credit card and my eyes closed! Fortunately, half of my portfolio from the other firm came along. I opened MMI in the basement of a rented home with a copier, a 2-line phone, a computer and a file cabinet. Sometimes I long for those days!
But, having no money, I sought very little advice. I prepared my own Articles of Incorporation and filed them myself. I did ask an accountant whether to opt for Subchapter S and I did so. There was no outsourcing. From 9:00 to 5:00, I answered the phones and coordinated repairs. After 5:00, I was a leasing agent – showing property until it was dark. Saturday morning, I was often found at a property doing cleaning and painting.
Most of my forms came from prior companies or from REALTOR associations. Yes, it would have been better to get all that advice. Today, I would say it’s essential. Times are very different today from 23 years ago. At least, in Maryland, there is plenty of regulation and what we can do varies from county to county, city to city. I would not try it today the same way I did it in 1987.
Did you create a business plan? If so, what did the plan entail?
I’m going to treat this like a trick question – you didn’t ask when I created my plan. So, no, I did not create a plan in 1987. In fact, I knew nothing about running a business back then. All I cared about was staying in business and generating enough cash to keep the wolves away.
Then, I read a business-changing book, The E-Myth Revisited by Michael Gerber. This book convinced me I was working IN my business instead of ON my business. After more than 15 years, I realized that all I owned was a job. I had nothing to sell and no plan to make my business grow. So I started working on that condition. I had a couple of property managers working for me and I needed more. I planned some expansion. With that, I would have to train people to do what I do just the way I would do it myself. So, I wrote a 200 page training manual and started teaching. Today, I have 9 managers – some of the best in the area. I developed checklists to enable them to properly inspect a property, how to secure a new account and turn-in the right paperwork, how to lease a property, and, again, turn-in the right paperwork, how to close out a tenancy and even how to close out an owner’s account. Today, we manage more than 200 homes and I don’t manage any of them! We have now expanded into condominium and homeowner’s association management, and, in about 5 years, have 12 communities with more than 1,100 units. Already, I have a business! I stopped doing the clients accounting and I stopped answering the phones myself. In fact, I never check my voicemail – someone does that for me. My job: get new business, hire and train the staff. I’m working on my business!
What were some of the greatest challenges you faced in getting your company off the ground in the beginning?
Of course, money is always and issue. But, the truth is, it is not as important as one might think. Plan to spend only what you can make it go as far as it can. There are lots of ways to get business without spending a ton of money on advertising – and some of those means are more effective and generate better quality business. I’m talking about networking. Those early days, you’d hear me say I don’t have time to do that. Today, that’s my #1 duty. Only the business owner can sell the business like a business owner. I have to be face to face with prospective clients and strategic partners on a daily basis. How can I do that and still do the accounting and inspect the properties?
It all boils down to making choices. You can do it all yourself or you can find ways to get the help you need and to use it effectively. READ, READ, READ – read motivational books. Read business books. Read success stories. Learn from everything you read. For me, the challenge was that I didn’t know, I didn’t read, I didn’t listen to people who knew. Now, maybe you’re listening to me;)
At what point did you hire your first employee, and for what position? How did you recruit good employees?
I thought I needed a secretary. Maybe I did – we still used typewriters in those days. She did answer phones when I was out – that was good for business. My next hire was a bookkeeper – no reason why I couldn’t get away from the computer a few hours a day.
I made good hires only when I was lucky. I made my share of bad hires, too. Why did this happen? Well, I didn’t develop job descriptions. I didn’t visualize the perfect hire. Most importantly, in the early days, I did no training. I told them what to do and left them to themselves – it’s not wonder they often failed in their positions.
To recruit good employees, provide a work atmosphere where everyone wants to work. Provide free training and support. Provide fun. Be professional, sure. But, you don’t need a stuffy environment. As a leader, balance the desire for work performance with the need for a healthy work environment. If you’ve made a bad decision, reverse that decision quickly. Bad employees NEVER get better! That’s N E V E R.
Of course, benefits and top wages are important. But it is often said that an employee values flex time or vacation more than an extra dollar. And, they’re cheaper for you. Many of my personnel are out in the field all day – that’s what they tell me. All I can do is evaluate their performance. Hours are unimportant and impossible for me to track, so I don’t sweat it. And, you know, I often see them in the office in the evening or on weekends. The concept must work. I once heard that the best investment a company can make is to buy its executive a laptop. They’ll take them on vacation and will steal away from the beach for an hour or two to check their email. But, it’s their decision and their schedule. They’ll love it.
Oh, and that networking thing – it doesn’t just get business. I have hired people right out of my networking groups. These are people that I have personally come to know. What better way to hire?
Any employee horror stories? Any doozy interview questions? How many employees do you currently have?
Not every reference is as valuable as it might seem. I once hired a person because a close friend recommended the guy. Turned out, this guy had become a coke addict and alcoholic. He was partying in my office with wine, women and drugs – all night long. But, during the day, he was stealing money from our clients.
I’m not the best person to ask about how to interview, but I do have three pieces of hiring advice: (1) shut up and listen; (2) ask questions that force the interviewee to tell stories of how they deal with problems they may face and (3) have at least one or two other members of your staff interview each applicant.
I have 5 full-time employees in the management company, one in the home improvement company. All tolled, there are 15 of us, but the rest are independent contractors. We’re basically a two-tiered management structure with me as the CEO and our controller serving in an executive capacity. All the rental and community managers report to me; paid staff reports primarily to him.
Hire out of promote from within?
Promotion from within in a nice concept, but there can be too great an emphasis placed on giving to the existing staff when they may not have the skills to advance. Back to that job description – if the existing staff can fill the job and their job would be easier to fill than the current vacancy, it’s a no-brainer. Otherwise, give them a chance to compete, but open the position to outside applicants, too.
What equipment, software, knowledge, etc. are required to start/run a property management company?
We have to know everything about everything! I still have a small firm, but we’re now growing at 30% or more annually. So, our computers have had to be linked through a network. Now, our property managers have to have remote access to email and files (and you want them using YOUR systems so you retain the data when they leave). Even the phone systems have become complex: IP phones, Blackberries and SmartPhones. We have to support all of this – whether we own the equipment or our staff owns it.
Accounting software has evolved into information databases and the internet access portals for the clients. That’s not too complex! So, either you have to know everything about everything or you have to hire someone who does. If you have the luxury of hiring, see the previous interview question, you must hire your contractors and vendors with equal care. Then, it’s better to hire, but try to keep-up on technology to help ensure that everyone is performing. It’s no different for me than evaluating a painter. I used to paint, so I know how long it takes to paint a room. I also set-up our computer systems and I know what I want them to do – I just don’t want to troubleshoot the problems myself.
How do you get customers/business? What kind of marketing materials do you use? Has your approach to getting business and growing your business changed significantly over time?
We spend a great deal of money on advertising – most of it through the internet. We use pay-per-click services; some targeting property management, some not. Making the phones ring is not that hard. Having them properly answered, having a skilled salesperson on your end of the line is the real challenge.
Over time, we’ve learned that people who call on ads have no one else to call – they have no experience and they have no knowledgeable friends. Referrals are your best source of business. Today, there are all kinds of referral networks, trade associations and networking organizations – join them! You can’t eliminate advertising, but you can sure enhance the results. Develop a plan to approach and evaluate your best strategic partners and work that plan. The business will come.
What do you wish you had known about business when you were first starting out? What advice would you give to a new business owner or someone looking to start or acquire a business?
It can no longer be done of $5,000 and be competitive. Our software alone took $18,000 to implement and we pay almost $10,000 annually for licenses. Our computers would cost $50,000 or more to replace. When you have the finances, spend carefully and in a controlled manner. Budgeting is a lost art. Develop a budget and look at it regularly – I recommend quarterly.
Spend your time and effort growing the business, but make sure you handle it when you get it. Referrals are only good when they’re good referrals. You don’t need bad PR when you’re starting out. You want every customer to be your ambassador.
Do you have or have you ever had someone you’d consider a mentor? What did you learn from them?
I’m a worker. I always have been. Although not necessarily an answer to the question, it’s good to recognize that running a business takes long hours for several years. I don’t know how many years – I’m still working long hours. I do it because I love it. But, if you’re not a worker now, you won’t be much more of a worker when you own the joint. If you’re more into punching a clock, punch someone else’s.
Yes, I worked with a partner when I started in real estate, a guy who was old enough to have retired from his first career and was starting another. He saw my energy and was generating more business than he wanted to handle. I’m not sure I had the willingness to do some of the hard things – the networking and marketing – that he expected, so it didn’t work out. But, I certainly learned that those were the things that made him successful; not the busy work. His name was George. George carried a briefcase to work – and eventually carried a larger, file system case. No, not instead, in addition to the briefcase! One day, George walked in with nothing but a clipboard. Everyone noticed. George decided all he really needed to carry was a listing form and a contract.
It’s really easy to get bogged down by paperwork. And, there is important paperwork, no doubt. But, in the end, unless you’re getting and keeping business, none of that paperwork will pay the bills. Dump the briefcase and get to what’s important just as soon as you possibly can – that’s what separates the business owners from the rest.
How has the real estate business changed since you were first starting out? What do you think about where your local market is right now?
Look outside right now. Look again in 12 hours – that’s how much change there has been. George would need the large case just to carry the forms to complete a single sale! We’re much more disclosure-oriented today and the paperwork reflects all that. In fact, some of us not so jokingly say that we think if we disclose enough, we won’t disclose anything. If you buy them in paper, they won’t read it. Case in point: The US Congress. No more 2-page bills. They’re a thousand pages and no one reads any of it.
Disclosure came because people were getting raw deals. Governments required the forms. Lawyers suggested more. Then, as our government is all too good at doing, they found ways to spend money they didn’t have. In the name of consumer protection, they started licensing agencies and programs. I know for a fact that there’s no way to stay in full compliance. I monitor the performance of my staff with regard to such compliance and it’s a never ending job. they just can’t meet all the deadlines and still have time to make all the money. So, we’re forced to do the best we can do and resolve to strive for better, but we’ll never get to perfect.
I’m in the Washington, DC market. Even here, we’re suffering, but not like other places in the US. Government is growing and with it, all the support systems. Values have come down, but mainly because they were, here like everywhere else, artificially inflated due to an unrealistic expectation that the euphoria would never end. Well, it ended here, too. But, there’s always room for a good company to grow and we’ve never stopped marketing, networking and training. As a result, both our rental department and our community management departments are growing by double digits. They’re carrying the home improvement company along for the ride. It’s a good thing I’m finally working on running my business because I believe we are doing a better job now than when we were struggling.
What do you attribute your success to?
I found my niche. I have knowledge of construction and maintenance and I have a good understanding of accounting. That covers about 90% of what we do. But, my networking efforts and my quest for designations have taken me places all around the country where I have been able to learn from people who were not my next-door competitor. People half way across the country are much more willing to tell their secrets.
After reading The E-Myth, I began to redirect my efforts to growing staff and it has paid-off. Our gross revenues are up 400% over 6 years. With a few extra bucks, you can hire more staff, buy better software, move to more impressive space and simply look more successful. People are attracted to success – success breeds success, they say.
Also worthy of mention is age. Yes, I’m getting older. A wise, Jewish neighbor of mine once told me, on my 40th birthday, that “40 is a good age – people will grovel to you – let them.” I don’t know how much they’re groveling, but they sure seem to respect my staying power and accumulated knowledge. That helps get those referrals. But, I digress, this isn’t at all where I was going with the age thing. With age comes patience. We understand that there will be another opportunity; even a better one. We know that fortunes are generally not made overnight. We understand that our patience gives us an advantage over those who have not yet learned the skill. Several years ago, I was so close to making a purchase – three fixer upper townhouses for $150k. I’d fix each for about $10,000 or so and sell them for $75,000 each. A healthy profit in about 6 months. Well the owner wanted more and she got it. I couldn’t believe people paid $68,000, $73,000 and $88,000 for those places! One of them actually hired me to do the renovations and we charged a lot more than $10,000. And, I think all those people flipped them and sold them for a profit. I was wrong. I did not see that we were in the early stages of the housing boom. Well, my patience paid off. I refused to pay those prices. I did not get caught-up in the buying frenzy. Did I miss a deal or two? Of course. But I know so many people who kept buying and flipping and, surprise! They got caught with their pants down. Today, they’re losing one at a time to foreclosure and many will lose it all. Oh, and I’m still here – I’m not ready to buy all those properties they’re losing…for half of what they may have paid.
Where do you see yourself in 10 years? At what point do you think you’ll become less involved in the day to day operations of your business? Will you sell the business or tap a successor when you’re ready to retire?
I see myself floating on my yacht in 10 years. Three if I’m lucky. Property management businesses take about 30 seconds to sell, so that’s an option. My preference would be to find a successor and retain a piece. I’m also willing to merge with another firm if we can complement each other and become greater than the sum of our parts. I think about retirement. Funny you shoud ask about the 10 year number – that’s kind of the target. Meanwhile, I’d like to slow it down and I do see that in the future of my firm. All I really need to do is more of what I’ve been doing for the last 5 years.
What are you reading? Fiction or non-fiction? Do you have a favorite book? Real estate book?
I never was a reader. Only recently have I really started to enjoy reading. And, I do now enjoy a bit of fiction. For someone who doesn’t read very much, Chesapeake took me nearly 4 months with some 800 pages. Yesterday, I finished Abraham Lincoln: Team of Rivals – just shy of 750 pages. I am absolutely NOT a reader of real estate books. I’ve never read one that taught how to do it right – it’s all about doing it with no money and no risk. What I know about real estate enabled me to recognize (a) that you cannot use the no money concept in conjunction with no risk and (b) that most of what they taught was totally illegal.
Soccer or baseball? Europe or the beach? New York or LA? Orioles or Nationals? Redskins or Ravens? Wine or scotch?
Sunshine and water. We have a nice boat – some might call it a yacht, but we know what we really want. Lazy weekends anchored on a Chesapeake tributary with a rum drink and some music…that’s life. Now, I need to find it somewhere I can do it for more than 5 months out of the year. We have a lot of summer hobbies: the boat and a big Harley, but nothing in the winter. We do have a few favorite spots in Mexico and try to get there once or twice a year.
I’m looking for a sports team that will wear my company logo just because I’m paying for their kids educations by attending a single game…haven’t found that yet. I like baseball, football, hockey and NASCAR, but I’m tired of the money being more important than the game. So, I’ll get off the couch and workout or row a boat. It will make me healthier and help me retain my money so I can retire, even if not to the same neighborhood as the athlete.
*****
Rule the World, Become Rich, Retire Early
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Business Profiles, Entrepreneurship, Interviews, Real Estate on August 4th, 2009

Katie's Kingdom
For a while now, I’ve wanted to start making interviews a regular part of this blog. I think it will help me to keep delivering quality content to people. Instead of the blog being limited to my ideas for posts and things I can research or come up with to write about, interviews will allow me to share more different ideas and viewpoints on the blog. Plus, I get to ask people in depth questions about how to do things without seeming ridiculously nosey. I’m excited about it.
This is my first interview. It’s with Katie Lewis. I have known Katie for about 9 years, and she’s a person who has been predictably successful. To know her is to love her. She’s witty, charming and great with people. My wife and I sometimes talk about who of our friends we would feel comfortable hiring for this or that. I’m confident I couldn’t afford her, but I would hire Katie for any sales job in a heart beat.
Katie is currently an associate financial representative and works under one of the most successful financial planners in the country. At the tender age of 26, she’s already had several career stops, starting out in a real estate sales position, then building a title company from the ground up, staying with it until the time of sale before settling in her current career. She’s on track to retire before she’s 40. Katie and her husband Jared also recently had their first child, a son they named Ben. But enough build up, I’ll let you read about her in her own words:
Q: Why don’t you start by telling me a little about your educational background.
A: I went to Duchesne High School in St. Charles. I enjoyed my high school days, but a person is either a high school person or a college person. I was definitely a college person! I learned a lot in high school, but it didn’t exactly expose me to a lot of diversity… so I wanted the big college experience (with in-state tuition, of course). I looked at all the state schools and some out of state programs just for kicks. At the time I was going into computer science/mathematics, so University of Missouri-Rolla had some appeal, but MU stole the show. I loved the large campus and town. And now, because I moved to KC after graduation, I get the honor of defending my Tigers every day to all these Jayhawks and Cornhuskers. I started MU in 2000 and after one semester I realized that computer science was the most boring thing I had ever encountered. It was NOT for me. I changed to math, then psychology, then sociology, interdisciplinary studies, and finally business. Obviously I was a little lost because there was no major called “rule the world, become rich, retire early.” I graduated with honors in 2004 from the business school with an emphasis in Marketing and 2 minors (German and Sociology).
Q: What was your first job out of school?
A: In October of my senior year I was offered a job with Pulte Holmes in Kansas City. I was from St. Louis, so KC seemed like the anti-christ. The Royals suck, the Chiefs fans were scary, and how could one live in a city with a sub-par zoo?? All my friends were vying for positions as buyers or marketing for major companies. Those jobs never “wowed” me. Anyway, after much debate I accepted the job with Pulte. It was a commission job in a new city where i knew no one and I was scared. It turned out the be one of the best decisions I’ve ever made. The company is great, I worked with 15 people exactly like me and now those people are my closest friends. KC turned out to be better than “anti-christ” and I’ve been here for the past 5 years. I sold new homes for 2.5 years, working every weekend without fail. I made great money and it made things possible for my husband and me that we never dreamed of at such a young age. What I learned from Pulte: the big corporation is great to work for in terms of stability and consistency, but don’t kid yourself… they are still a corporation and they don’t care about you. don’t give up your family time/holidays, etc., because at the end of the day they don’t care and you can’t get that time back. It all changes in the blink of an eye – your VP gets let go. A new VP comes in. They might hate you or your style. You are starting from scratch again. Or your division gets work from the corporate office of major changes. Those changes aren’t negotiable.
Q: How did you end up running your own title company? Did you start it from scratch? If so, how did you get customers and compete with more established businesses? Did you create a tangible business plan?
A: After Pulte, I was ready to get my weekends back and I didn’t want to work for a large company any more. I received financial backing and lots of guidance from a gentleman in StL. He owned 15+ companies and was interested in opening a new one in KC. Opening a title company is quite simple if you already have an underwriter in line, which he did. All the title searching was done thru the StL location, so I just needed an office in KC. There is a lot of money to be made in the title business because you can close so many deals in a day! It’s definitely a sales role though. You have to sell yourself first to get in the door of the mortgage company. Then you have to sell your company’s ability to do it faster and better than the competition… at a lower price of course. Then you have to actually get the deal, work up the closing documents (by coodinated efforts of the title company, mortgage broker, lender, and possibly the other party involved if it’s a purchase and not a refinance). Lastly, you have to sell yourself at the closing table. The borrower needs to trust you that you’re telling them all they need to know when staring at a stack of 80 pages of paper. I would normally have to make them like me, then explain their loan, sometimes resell their loan and tell them why it was a good loan/rate for their situation, and then make them happy before they walked out. A mortgage broker can call any title company they want. The only way to keep that broker calling you (and telling others how great you are) is to be PERFECT. I had to be quick, accurate, and sell their deal at the table if the borrower started getting nervous. Please don’t take that the wront way – borrowers are very likely to “panic” at the closing table. It’s a lot of paperwork, money and words they don’t understand. It’s scary!! It was my job to make them feel ok with their own decision.
Q: What does a title company do?
A: Title companies research the property to determine if there are any liens, owed taxes, etc. Also the coordinate the proration of homeowners association dues, homeowners insurance, property taxes, escrows from the lender, etd. Also they coordinate the transfer of funds between parties. You have to use a title company as a third party that is neutral. We don’t know the client or the lender so it’s just business.
Q: What is an underwriter?
A: Basically an underwriter backs the title company’s search. When you and Rachel bought your property in StL someone did a search to make sure they owner actually owned it and determined what liens/rights were held to that property. If they missed a lien, then the underwriter (like Old Republic – the largest) would pay to have this resolved, whether in court or otherwise with title insurance. Without an underwriter, title companies are just saying “looks good to us”. The underwriter guarantees it or backs it. your title is only as solid as the underwriting.
Q: What were the terms involved between you and the financial backer?
A: I had to get enough business to make it profitable in under 2 months or he would pull his name and his support. I had to get my notary and my E&O but the rest I could run thru his other businesses. It was very advantageous for him to stay involved because title companies make a lot of cash quickly if you have the client base.
Q: What equipment, software, knowledge, etc. is necessary to start and run a title company? How did you acquire those things?
A: I rented office space in the great business park in overland park, ks. All you need to run a title company is a computer, a fax, and a FedEx account. As I mentioned, I became a notary and had an E&O that is required for all notaries. The software needed to work up a HUD can be purchased from several different companies that specialize in this. That was easy too!
Q: How long did you own/run the business?
A: I ran the company for 6 months before someone came along and wanted to buy the client base. They approached the gentleman in StL and they negotiated the deal. He sold the name of the company as well so it was a very quiet “transition” that the clients never really saw.
Q: Did you have employees? Did you have an accountant?
A: No employees, just me working a LOT of hours. I ran my own payroll and the business money was sent to an accountant in St. Louis.
Q: Why did you decide to sell the business?
A: We were approached to sell the KC piece of the business by a company out of Colorado. They offered just a lump sum of $ and that was that. The thought was that I would just find a new client base, build it up for another 6 months and sell again since that worked so well, but I was not on board. I was done selling for a while.
Q: How did it happen?
A: The company from CO contacted us as well as 3 other title companies in KC and made a very premature offer. After several very long conversations they decided to go with our title company because we were already operating off of the StL main office so it would not be hard to transition to operating off of their CO main office. Also, my overhead was so low (just me) and my margins were quite high. Very appealing to them
Q: Did a lawyer or accountant assist you with any part of the sale?
A: All parts of the sale had a lawyer involved.
Q: What are you doing now? How did get from owning to title company to the job you’re doing now? Do you miss being self-employed? Do you think you’ll ever be self-employed again?
A: Now I work at Northwestern Mutual for one of the top reps in the country (#5 this year – woo hoo!). I actually found this job thru the man who rented the office next to me at the business park in Overland Park, KS. My role now is quite different, mostly office work and lots of phone interaction with clients. I have been here 2 years already and love it. My boss is my employer, not actually Northwestern Mutual so he and I work hand-in-hand. It’s a big corporation but I work for one individual and he is sort of “self-employed”. I now am licensed in insurance and investments and we have a special niche market – we focus on tax efficient ways to build wealth. The client base is mainly lawyers, doctors, business owners, etc. I don’t miss being self employed because this job gives me lots of freedom and my boss empowers me so I don’t feel micro mananged. If you are interested in titles or “climbing the ladder” this is not the job for you. That doesn’t impress me anymore – all I care about is the pay check and job satisfaction.
Q: What do you attribute your success to?
A: That’s a hard one!! I would say that I’m very fortunate to have a great work ethic and I love talking to people so it makes it easy to put myself out there. I’m surprised how many people are afraid of rejection or even just picking up a phone to call a client. One of my largest flaws is that I love to please people. That makes me a wonderful employee and business partner, but sometimes I take on a bit more than I should to remain sane
If it isn’t slightly uncomfortable you aren’t pushing yourself enough, right!?!
Q: What are you reading? Fiction or non-fiction? Do you have a favorite book?
A: I am reading Baby Proof (book about a couple who gets married with the intention of never wanting children and then the husband changes his mind) and the first Twilight book (I can’t stand hearing about something all the time and not knowing what all the fuss is about). I don’t have a favorite book – I’m a new reader. I never made reading a priority until a few years ago so I have a lot of catching up to do.. My husband is a book addict so he’s always handing me some boring history thing to read. No thanks. It’s funny to say, but I think everyone should put their flaws out on display in order to make them work on them. I’m a slow reader since I have not done a lot of reading (but i memorize every word I read) and I’m a terrible swimmer
I grab a book and jump in the pool all the time, but that doesn’t make me good at either just yet!!
Q: Will Ben be an only child?
A: Nope, we want 3 or 4 and then plan on either adopting or foster parenting.
Q: Has gender been a significant factor in your career? How?
A: I have always worked in predominantly male fields – I think I do well in these enviroments because I’m rather unemotional. I do not cry easily, I sometimes talk harshly or pointedly to people when I think they are being intellectually challenged so I do not get offended if someone talks pointedly at me. I like the investment world and for whatever reason that is a male field. I think you have to have a certain “super man” complex to be in a commission business and men seem to have that more than women. Women think things through too much and are too calculating to work in a commission based world where you never know if you’ll eat again.
Q: Soccer or baseball? Europe or the beach? New York or LA? Seinfeld or South Park?
A: Soccer. Europe. Jamaica. Seinfeld. Steak. Ice cream. Rum and Coke. St. Louis Cardinals.
Q: Where do you see yourself in 10 years?
A: Funny you should ask, I am actually set to retire in 10 years. My husband will be a principal or superintendent by then and I have my retirement plan in line. We joke that I will be Jared’s secretary and secretly run the school with him as the “face” of the operation. In all honesty, I don’t know what I will do. I like being behind the scenes and not selling but I love to work so I’ll never settle down. I have a list called “me” of all the things I will do when I have time so I’ll work on that as well. I will probably get my masters because I can’t stand the idea of Jared having more education than me. Ultimately, I would like our mailbox to read “The Doctors Lewis”. Also, after our kids are gone, we will move back to Columbia and be professors at Mizzou.
Q: What advice would you give to someone interested in starting or acquiring a business?
A: I would say you need to be ready to work your ass off and really assess yourself. Can you handle being rejected over and over and over again? It’s important that you are resiliant and focused.
***
Having a New House
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Frugal Living, Managing Finances, Real Estate on July 22nd, 2009

Taken from our back deck, that pond has fish in it.
We went from about 800 square feet to about 1450 square feet not counting the basement. We lost half a bathroom in the process, somehow (we still have two toilets but now we only have one shower, in a bathroom half the size of the two bathrooms we had before). We gained another unit of about the same size and a couple new tenants.
We absolutely love the new place, but having it has made it harder to control our spending than before. For one, any time you move into a place that’s bigger than where you lived before, you have to fight the desire to fill it up with stuff. We’re not planning on buying new furniture, but our bedroom is pretty big and we’re talking about moving up to a king size bed.
We also have spent more money on consumer oriented goods recently. All of them have been for me, so I don’t have anyone to point at but myself. I’m typing on the most expensive of those purchases as we speak. We talked about just getting a desktop and a netbook, but I was seduced when the salesperson started showing me all the nifty stuff the mac could do.
On top of that, our new home is over 100 years old, and there are plenty of things we’d like to do with it. We have a brand new back deck that we’re going to buy patio furniture for. We’re probably going to buy a potted tree for the front one (the best place to sit and watch the world go by). We have a spot picked out for a home gym in the basement that will require buying several things (a good pair of running shoes is still the cheapest way to get in shape!), though I think it will get more use and save more money than a gym membership, so that should pay off. Read my friend Josh’s comments on the home gym. I’m finally in a place where I can take his advice on constructing my home gym.
Living so close to a park has also really made me want to get a bike. My wife already told me that if I get one, she gets one. Numerous other projects have popped up, including adding a shower to the bathroom that doesn’t have one. All of these things will cost money.
Making things more difficult is the fact that Rachel’s making money now. I think, in some ways, it’s given us a false sense of security. We need to revisit our budget and try to see where all the things we want to do fit in. It’s getting too easy to justify purchases lately. I think it’s good to have to wait for things for awhile. You avoid impulse spending and are less likely to experience buyer’s remorse.
My point is that it’s easy to spend a lot of money when you buy a new house. The thing is, you probably just spent a lot of money buying the house to begin with and should probably be focused on how you’re going to pay that back instead of how much stuff you can get to shove into it. Try to keep that in mind. We’ll try if you try. Thanks for reading.
On a totally unrelated note, I’ve been getting a tremendous amount of comment spam. It’s getting to the point that I’m afraid I might have to add one of those ‘are you human’ boxes to the site. I’m somewhat afraid that would discourage commenting. I know that I sometimes feel compelled to comment on something and then don’t if it ends up being too much trouble. If you read this blog (or others) and have an opinion, I’d love to hear from you by email or in the comments.
Some Legal Types of Eviction
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Real Estate on July 21st, 2009

Since we just moved into our new home, we have brand new tenants living below us. They’re people we didn’t choose, and that we’d never met until just a few days ago. I’m happy to say that they seem to be a better fit than we’d likely find on our own. He’s a fourth year resident at Saint Louis University, and she’s a nurse who’s temporarily staying home with their two young children. They’re a cute family, and they seem very nice. I’m confident they’ll be good tenants for as long as they decide to stay.
We’ve been lucky in recent years when it comes to tenants in our other rental property as well. We’ve had the same tenants for about three years in that property. They rarely ask for anything, and usually fix things on their own when things need to be fixed. They pay their rent on time, and I almost never hear a peep out of them. That property has been around 6 driving hours away from us for the last 4 years – now we’re around two hours from it. So that’s another nice thing about moving to StL.
Having two sets of tenants has the “worst case scenario” part of my mind working hard, though. What if they default and refuse to pay? What if they both break their leases and move out? What if both places stay empty for extended periods of time, and we’re stuck paying the extra mortgage/taxes/insurance with no income to show for it? What if I have to evict someone (I have once)?
I’d like to briefly digress into a little bit of land ownership theory. I think one of the most difficult jobs the government has is trying to decide who to help. I typically trumpet a free market view point, but if you’re making the law too beneficial for landowners it puts them in a position where they can potentially mistreat tenants, especially in poorer housing situations. If I mistreated my tenants, they would just go somewhere else. My location in St. Louis has lots of available housing. It’s a desirable area to live near a popular park and lots of popular restaurants, but they could find another place to live, and, if they had to, spend more money. Not every tenant is in such a powerful bargaining position.
Do you make it easy for the tenant to force the landlord to do things? Or do you let the landlord do what he will and let the market for housing play out? One of the difficult things about letting the free market decide questions like these is that it could potentially leave some people without homes, or without a refrigerator that works, or plumbing, etc.
Turning back to the actual subject of the post, what are the general types of eviction? This isn’t a how to (though that might be a good idea for a later post), but rather just a primer on eviction in general. There are four basic types:
1. Actual – For an actual eviction to occur, the landlord must wrongfully keep the tenant from having physical possession of the property they’re leasing. The landlord has to physically exclude the tenant from the property. If the tenant is kept out of part of the property, it’s an actual eviction. Ex. the landlord changes the locks while the tenant is away.
2. Constructive – This occurs when the landlord’s bad acts keep the tenant from being able to benefit from being able to use and enjoy the property. There’s a catch to this one, though. The tenant has to leave the property to be able to claim that he or she is a victim of constructive eviction. I think an example of this might be if the landlord refused to fix the only toilet and the tenant moved out. In either constructive or actual eviction, I believe the tenant would have a right to quit paying rent (as always, I’m not your attorney – get legal advice from someone licensed in your jurisdiction).
3. Retaliatory – This basically is a doctrine that states that if a landlord can be required to do something by the tenant, like fix something, the landlord can’t then evict the tenant for the tenant’s decision to report the landlord for doing whatever it is that he or she did that isn’t in compliance with a housing or other authority.
4. Self-help – most jurisdictions have statutes in place that require that a landlord use a judicial type of eviction to get rid of his or her tenants. A couple states allow you to use self-help to get the tenant out of your house (like changing the locks when the tenants are away). The risk, for landlords, is that while the eviction process is underway, the tenants could be trashing the place. You don’t want to walk into a place you just evicted a tenant from without a Hazmat suit on. Even the states that allow self-help require that it be peaceful. There aren’t any wild west provisions out there that allow you to physically throw the tenants out of your house.
Do you notice anything about those types of eviction? I don’t know about you, but I would say they’re set forth in a way that is designed to protect the tenant (and not the landlord). Sure, a landlord can go through a judical eviction procedure, where the Sheriff goes over to the house and asks the people to leave, but by the time you’ve given the tenant notice and gone through the procedure, your house might be in substantially worse shape than before.
Then again, tenants need to be protected from “slumlords” who let their property go to waste. It’s a fine line, and one I don’t know exactly where I come down on. As a landlord myself, I want to be protected, but I also don’t want people in a less advantageous position to be taken advantage of.
I usually fight the urge to write about things like this. If this bored you to tears, let me know by email or in the comments. In any case, I’ll try to do better tomorrow. Thanks for reading.
Do Better Next Time
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Real Estate on July 15th, 2009

My wife and I just closed on our new multi-family. I am out of town for work this week, writing this in the comfort of my hotel room, but when I go back to St. Louis, I’ll be going home to our new place instead of the place we’ve been subletting. It’s an exciting feeling. Meanwhile, most of the responsibility for getting things going at our new place have fallen on my wife (as so many things have throughout this process). It’s just one of those twisted coincidences that I end up out of town the week we close on our place.
Looking back on the process, there are some things I think we did well. We stayed conservative about what we could afford. We got a property capable of producing revenue of 10% of the purchase price annually if fully occupied. At the same time, there are a lot of things that I would do a differently, too. For instance, a couple of weeks before closing, I mentioned to my wife that it was important to me that the sellers leave the basement completely empty (it was packed full of stuff when we saw the house). She communicated this to our realtor, who told her, “there’s really not much you can do about that.” (I’m not crazy about our StL realtors professionalism or advocacy – but I have a great Kansas City realtor if anyone in that area ever needs a recommendation).
Rachel told me that our realtor said that there was nothing we can do about making sure they empty the house completely. I disagreed, and sent our realtor a note saying that if the house was not empty to our satisfaction at the time of our final walk through, we wouldn’t sign at closing.
Our realtor then wrote me telling me that if we didn’t sign as scheduled (our realtor isn’t crazy about me, either), then we would be in breach of contract and we would need to consider whether it was worth it to us to proceed under those circumstances.
As a practical matter, being in breach of contract means nothing until someone actually files a suit. If that had happened for some reason, they would have to explain to the judge how they were damaged and demonstrate they had a claim to survive a motion to dismiss. I think a judge would find it unreasonable if we asked them to remove their personal property and they filed a breach of contract suit against us. At the very least, a mediation likely would have been ordered. For one, closings get pushed back all the time for all kinds of reasons. Further, it would likely be cheaper for the sellers (two non-lawyers) to simply have their excess stuff removed than to pay the cost of prosecuting a breach of contract suit. (On the flip side, it would likely be cheaper for us to just hire someone to move it out rather than defend the suit, but I didn’t want to do that;)) I told the realtor all of this (and more). I tried to be polite, but after having several problems with this realtor throughout the process (all long stories), I’m not sure I came off that way. I hope I wasn’t too bad.
In any case, if that was something that was important to us, we should have put it in our initial offer. It’s the kind of tack on language that gets thrown in to contracts all the time. ”Seller agrees to remove all personal property before closing unless specifically identified and agreed to in this document or in an addendum to this contract.” The seller is worried about getting the best possible price. The seller typically isn’t going to balk at this kind of language in an offer. It would have been easy to do and would have protected our interest in this particular circumstance. That was my mistake.
Ultimately, this did not end up being an issue. The sellers got their stuff out. They were the kind of people that took good care of their house, and were nice enough to leave the place nice and (mostly) empty for us. Even when we were having this back and forth dispute with the realtor, my wife and I suspected this based on having met the people that we bought the place from.
All in all, I think we did well with our purchase. We got it at a good price and ended up getting lots of add-ons and throw-ins after the inspection (about 30k worth of extra, necessary upgrades). From a negotiation standpoint, however, I think a buyer should add in lots of extras into the initial offers. It’s easy to focus only on price (that’s what the average realtor would like you to do, because that makes their life easier). If you ask for lots of things and the sellers focus on price because the add-ons seem small, you might end up getting a better deal overall. In any case, if it’s your first opportunity to make an offer, I would put in all the things that help optimize your the property to fit your needs, especially in a down market (like this one). If you have a negotiation story, or another perspective, I would love to hear it (via comments or email). Best of luck, and thanks for reading.
Should You Refinance?
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Real Estate on June 23rd, 2009

I hear a lot of talk about refinancing lately. I think it’s because although rates are relatively down right now, a lot of people think they’re going to be on their way up soon. The Federal Reserve is printing money and putting it into circulation. An increased money supply, in theory, will create a risk of inflation. When the money supply increases, the thought is that people will spend more money and bid up the cost of goods and market prices. Scarcity gives money value, and as money becomes less scarce, it has less value. This, of course, is all in theory. Right now, inflation isn’t occurring at the rate that everyone fears, because even though the money supply is being increased, we have a generation of people that are all simultaneously tightening their belts. Blatant rampant consumerism is no longer en vogue. It’s been replaced – frugality is the new hip thing.
If you read this site with any regularity, you know that my wife and I are in the process of buying a multi-family piece of real estate and selling our condo. It’s been a rush of mortgages, titles, negotiations and closing costs. To be honest, it’s been fun in a lot of ways. What won’t be fun, however, will be paying all the closing costs on our loan. When we were shopping for lenders, I would always ask for what I referred to as a “term sheet.” Lenders prefer to call this a “good faith estimate.” To me, if you’re making a deal about something, it’s a term sheet. But I digress.
The truth about closing costs is they can be fairly substantial. Real estate has generated a tremendous number of jobs. Mortgage brokers, real estate brokers and agents, title companies and appraisers all make their living off of these transactions. They all chip away at the transaction. Everyone gets their piece. Many of those pieces are negotiable.
Here are some of the costs typically associated with the loan and closing: loan origination, title insurance, escrow fee, application fee, appraisal. Other fees may apply as well. Here’s an example of what we’re paying.
Credit Report – $50
Processing Fee – $60
Underwriting Fee – $435
Wire Transfer Fee – $25
Escrow Fee – $150
Title Insurance – $800
Courier Fee – $60
CPL – $25
Wire Fee – $25
File Retention Fee – $8
Recording Fee – $120
We’re at $1,758 already, and we haven’t even gotten into insurance, taxes, or page any of the mortgage or interest. We’re giving a lot of people a living by buying houses. It’s easy to see, when you think about how many people are employed by this industry, and we haven’t even mentioned people who work in home improvement or building industries.
If you’re thinking about refinancing, consider checking out this handy dandy refinance calculator. The key is seeing how long it will take you to recoup the money it would cost you to refinance. Then you have to think about whether you think you’ll stay in the home long enough to get that value back. Numbers are the only relevant consideration when it comes to a refinance. A good rule of thumb is that if you can get a whole percentage point difference in your interest rate, it’s a good idea to refinance. That being said, you still have to compare the dollars saved by refinancing to the amount you’ll pay to do so. Keep that in mind. Good luck, and thanks for reading.
Quotable Quotes
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Business Profiles, Real Estate on June 18th, 2009

There’s a section at the end of the latest Forbes full of quotes. It’s labeled “thoughts on the business of life.” A couple of the quotes caught my eye and I thought I’d comment on one of them here. Please indulge me this slight digression from our personal finance conversation.
This quote is from a famous, perhaps the most famous real estate developer in America, Donald Trump. If there’s such a thing as a business celebrity, and there is, it’s Trump. This what he has to say, according to Forbes:
When I build something for somebody, I always add $50 million or $60 million onto the price. My guys come in, they say it’s going to cost $75 million. I say it’s going to cost $125 million and I build it for $100 million. Basically, I did a lousy job. But they think I did a great job.
The reason I’m reproducing that here is because I’m simply struck by the incredible arrogance it must have taken to say something like that. He’s proud of it. He’s bragging that he spent more money than the job required, but because he wisely built in a $50 million cushion, he surprised the customer by doing the job for less than he said it would require. It’s pretty typical advice for anyone with someone to answer to – Under Promise, and Over Deliver. Building in the cushion makes a lot of sense. It’s sound advice.
Trump is not someone that I’m particularly impressed with. He has had some success. He’s a big brand. He’s done an excellent job of marketing himself and promoting his celebrity. He’s made some money, an estimated $3 billion, according to Forbes, but he, of course, says he’s worth $10 billion. He’s just not my kind of guy. The showy, bravado that he carries himself with isn’t for me. He’s very authoritative, bad with people, impressed with himself. I tend to be a lot more impressed with humility. I admire how Warren Buffett uses his influence and carries himself. He’s humble and frugal, despite his success and intelligence. Buffett has the type of grace I’d like to exhibit when I have success in life. I don’t think I’ve ever heard him pat himself on the back for something he’s done right. I’m of the opinion that if people are something great, they shouldn’t have to tell you about it all the time. I feel like Trump is constantly trying to tell us how great he is. As Nolan Ryan would say, you’re not my guy, friend. Thanks for reading.
Challenge Conventional Wisdom
Posted by: Todd Metheny in Real Estate on June 9th, 2009

I try to be a person who challenges the people around me, and as a rule, I love meeting people who challenge conventions. Sometimes I find myself repeating something I’ve heard and believed all my life only to hear someone pipe up and question it. “Why would that be?”, they ask, or “are you sure you don’t mean ‘x’?” Being questioned is always a blow to your pride, but a lot of the time, people have good questions and bring up valid points. It forces you to come up with an answer, on the spot, and demonstrate whether you know what you’re talking about or alter your assertion. So here’s a piece of conventional wisdom you should believe and follow: Don’t believe everything you hear.
My wife and I are bucking a couple of pieces of conventional wisdom with a couple of decisions we’re making in relation to the real estate we’re in the process of purchasing. Here’s one thing I’ve always heard that I’m going against: always go with a 15 year mortgage if you can. We’re going with a 30 year mortgage. A 15 is available to us. The reason we’re going with the 30 is because, for us, we’re being offered the same interest rate on both a 15 and a 30. So we’re opting to go with the 30. If we pay it off over 30 years, we’ll pay thousands more in interest. Of course, we have no intention of paying it off over 30 years. We’re planning on paying the mortgage off quickly, making extra payments each month that go straight to principal. Because the interest rate is the same for either one, we think it makes sense to retain the added flexibility that the 30 offers. If we reach a point where one of us loses our job or we need the extra money because of some other kind of emergency, we can reduce our payment down to the minimum.
This brings us to the next piece of conventional wisdom – never take an FHA loan when you can take a conventional, because you can’t afford to throw away the extra money on private mortgage insurance (PMI). We’re taking an FHA loan, and only putting 3.5% down on the property. Contrary to popular belief, there are not income limits for FHA loans (although they are primarily used by lower income families because of the PMI). We’re able to take a conventional loan. We have plenty of cash that we could put down (especially now that we’ve sold our place). We could put down 20% without any problem. The PMI makes the FHA loan more expensive. However, the conventional loan has a slightly higher interest rate. We ran the numbers, and the difference ends up being about $3,000, with the FHA loan being more expensive over the life of the loan. However, it frees up about $45,000 for us to use for other purposes. Unfortunately, I have some student loans. Most of my student loan debt is at pretty favorable interest rates, but some of it isn’t. The 45k would be more than enough to pay off my debt and potentially make some improvements and upgrades to the units that we’re buying. It’s also enough to pay off the 14k we owe on our other rental property, which is at 6% on an adjustable rate mortgage. Being an ARM, it could, of course, go up in the future. 6% isn’t bad at all, but we’d like to get rid of it in case inflation causes interest rates to rise in the future. That loan resets once a year. After paying off my bad student loan, our other rental property, and making a few specific improvements we have in mind, we’ll still have about 10k to add to our emergency fund. This will put us in a sound financial position going forward and put most of our debt in one place – our income producing multi-family, where we plan on living for the next few years. We’re going against the advice we’ve gotten all of our lives and determining what’s best for us based on the information at hand. I hope you’ll do the same. Thanks for reading.



